IRS Finalizes New Hardship Distribution Rules

March 07, 2020
Hardship Withdrawal

In October 2019, the IRS responded to the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 and the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 through its release of the final amendments to the hardship distribution regulations.  Thanks to these newly-amended regulations, plan sponsors will now have new customization options for their plan’s hardship distribution rules.  There are also provisions of these amended regulations that will require some administrative changes that plan sponsors will need to start implementing as early as January 1, 2020.

We’ve summarized the major implications for most plan sponsors in this article.

Hardship Deferral Suspension Eliminated – Mandatory

Starting January 1, 2020,  plans are no longer permitted to suspend participants from making salary deferrals into their retirement plan account after taking a hardship distribution.  Previously, sponsors could suspend participants from making deferrals for 6 months after taking a hardship withdrawal.  The original thinking was that if an employee truly needs to take a hardship withdrawal, then they should also suspend their salary deferrals to increase their take-home pay.  However, legislators have made it clear through this rule change that they’re more concerned with workers’ ability to retire than before.

This new rule means that participants who take hardship withdrawals after 12/31/2019 can’t be suspended from making deferrals.  However, hardships taken during 2019 that already have a suspension in progress would still apply the suspension until its expiration date, even if the expiration date is in 2020.

Removal of Requirement to Take Loans and Other Forms of Distributions First – Optional

The newly-issued rules now eliminate the requirement for a participant to exhaust their other forms of distributions and loans available under the plan before taking a hardship.  Since this change is optional, plan sponsors can customize their plan to suit their preference.

Ease of Hardship Verification – Optional

Plan sponsors can now rely on a written certification statement from the participant instead of having to review supporting documents to make a hardship determination. This will certainly make it easier for sponsors to fulfill their duties, but it may introduce more frequent abuse of the hardship withdrawal feature in their plan.  However, sponsors are still prohibited from authorizing a hardship withdrawal if they have knowledge that the participant’s need would not qualify for a hardship.

Availability of Earnings in Hardship Amount – Optional

Previously, hardships could only be taken from the principal contributions made to a participant’s retirement plan account. But the new rules have now expanded the amount available for hardship to include earnings as well.

New Safe Harbor Hardship Event for Federally-Declared Disasters

Traditionally, the IRS has maintained a safe harbor list of six safe harbor hardship events that qualified a participant as being in immediate and heavy financial need.  This list has consisted of the following events:

  • Expenses related to post-secondary education for the participant, spouse, or children in the next 12 months

  • Prevention of foreclosure of a primary residence 

  • Purchase of a primary residence 

  • Repairs or improvements to a primary residence 

  • Funeral expenses 

  • Medical expenses not covered by insurance

However, a new seventh safe harbor hardship reason has been added to make hardships available for expenses related to federally-declared disasters in an area determined by FEMA.

The changes to hardship withdrawals are designed to make it easier for participants to access their retirement account assets in times of need, but they also offer some administrative relief for plan sponsors as well by relaxing some of the previous restrictions that could be easily overlooked.

Related Articles

Identifying Related Employers: Part II – Control Groups

Identifying Related Employers: Part II – Control Groups

There are two major types of Related Employers: Affiliated Service Groups and Control Groups. Part I of this series discussed the general purpose of Related Employer rules, how they affect plan testing, and explained Affiliated Service Groups.   Why are the...

read more

Subscribe to receive our latest posts.


Articles posted on the ERISA Consultants Blog are provided for general informational purposes only. The materials and content are not intended to provide tax, legal, accounting, financial, or other professional advice. Readers are advised to seek out qualified professionals that provide advice for specific client circumstances. ERISA Consultants makes no warranties about the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in the published articles. While articles are generally published with the most up to date information, ERISA Consultants does not guarantee that the articles will be updated with the most recent information or reflect the most current laws and regulations. 

Third-party links included in any articles are not intended as, and should not be interpreted as, constituting or implying ERISA Consultants’ endorsement, sponsorship, or recommendation of third-party information, products, or services, unless expressly stated otherwise. ERISA Consultants is not affiliated with the owners or participants of any linked websites. The opinions expressed by any guest writers and/or article sources are strictly their own and do not necessarily represent those of ERISA Consultants. Please use caution when linking to other websites.

Information from the ERISA Consultants blog should be used at your own risk. Investing in securities involves risk, and there is always the potential of losing money. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Investment returns vary and may involve gains or losses.

Any articles or commentary included on the ERISA Consultants blog do not constitute a tax advice and cannot be used by any taxpayer to avoid penalties that may be imposed under the Internal Revenue Code on the taxpayer.